Fantasticon Milwaukee’s Weird Web of Lies, Sketchy Tactics and Law Breaking

We last talked about Fantasticon, which held its first event last fall, when we broke the story that they were out of money and wouldn’t run a second event. But beyond their staff’s obvious mismanagement which led to their closure, something felt off the more I read about their organization… so I began to dig.

What I found was a strange mixture of obfuscation and sketchy business tactics… and one instance where they broke the law.

That sounds more scandalous than it is, but still.

To begin though, and I hate that I have to say this again, the Fantasticon in Milwaukee was not related to Funfest Inc‘s touring Fantasticon shows. Nor is it related to the FantastiCon in the UK, and it definitely has no relation to the one in Denmark. Just a tip, when you’re starting a new convention: Google your name.

Seriously, it takes five seconds.

Anticompetitive Behavior
One of the most amazing things about Fantasticon’s meltdown was the tirade by convention chair “Henry Jones” (we’ll get to why that’s in quotes in a bit). He not only blamed the local fans for the failure of Fantasticon, but also the cancelled Awesome Con Milwaukee. In fact, they pretty much nailed Awesome Con Milwaukee up on a cross.

And that bit was weird.

Awesome Con Milwaukee’s cancellation just weeks before the convention was likely due to a lot of factors (including the low turnout at their Indianapolis show), but at no point was Fantasticon’s staff ever a friend to Awesome Con.

When Fantasticon Milwaukee was still expecting to run a second event, they already had their eyes set on expanding to a larger space – specifically the Wisconsin Center. In a comment on Facebook, Ben Penrod (President of Awesome Con) stated:

Screen Shot 2015-04-02 at 10.52.50 AM

So, if you follow me, one of the major factors behind Awesome Con Milwaukee’s cancellation was that they would not have been able to run a 2015 event (low attendance can be justified if you’re building a reputation in a region). And the reason they wouldn’t have been able to run a 2015 event was wholly Fantasticon’s doing.

Fantasticon didn’t start there though. The summer prior, Fantasticon’s convention chair was directly contacting people stating they were interested in going to Awesome Con Milwaukee telling them not to attend the other show via Facebook.

According to one Nerd & Tie reader who wrote to me, they had been directly contacted and told not to go to Awesome Con because they were “East coasters.” The chair pleaded with this person to support “Wisconsin’s Own.”


But here’s the thing: Fantasticon wasn’t Wisconsin’s own.

Who the heck is “Henry Jones?”
You may have noticed two names associated with the Milwaukee Fantasticon at this point, “Henry Jones” and the Michael in the screen shot above. More specifically, on all Facebook communications, Henry Jones is presented as the convention chair for the event. According to Henry Jones’s Facebook Page, he’s just a guy from Milwaukee, WI. Well, that’s all that I can glean at least, as he has the thing pretty locked down.

Screen Shot 2015-04-02 at 11.51.29 AM
Screen Shot 2015-04-02 at 11.51.56 AM

I spoke with Anime Milwaukee Convention Chair Corey Wood, and he assured me that “Henry Jones” was the Facebook contact he had for the organization. Likewise, it’s clear that the name was used when communicating with other groups – like the USS Chicago, who thanked “Henry Jones” on their website for a fan table.

I didn’t think twice about the name originally (beyond the fact that it’s shared with a cinematic icon) until I received an email from another Midwest Convention organizer (who would prefer to go unnamed) pointing it out, alleging that the real organizer was hiding his identity to protect his reputation.

And who was that person?

According to Fantasticon’s website about page (although it used to be more prominently mentioned on the site), the event was organized by “Phanatic Entertainment, LLC.”

Screen Shot 2015-04-02 at 11.55.15 AM

Five minutes on Google (and with the handy, dandy state of Illinois) I was easily able to find that “Phanatic Entertainment, LLC” is an Illinois based LLC owned by one Michael E. Bollow.

Screen Shot 2015-04-02 at 11.57.33 AM

This would be, presumably, the Michael E. Bollow who had previously been randomly telling people not to go to Awesome Con, saying Fantasticon was “Wisconsin’s Own.”

Never mind that Michael Bollow is from the Chicago area, and was just as much an “out of towner” as the Awesome Con staff he disparaged. But hey, why does that matter when you can create a fake Facebook page for your con chair and just pretend they live in Wisconsin?

Edit: I’ve also been told by my sources that said Michael Bollow likes to cosplay as Indiana Jones… so… yeah.

The History of Phanatic Entertainment, LLC
Fantasticon wasn’t Michael Bollow and Phanatic Entertainment, LLC’s first convention. They recently ran the eleventh Military History Fest (formerly Reenactor Fest) in St. Charles, IL. Oddly enough, there was briefly a post about the event on the Fantasticon Milwaukee Facebook page from early this year that was deleted in March just after the Fantasticon 2015 cancellation was made public.

Which is weird, right? I mean, unless you’re trying to separate the public images of the cons for some reason.

Bollow’s Phanatic Entertainment, LLC also ran the CYPHAN conventions, which took place between 2010 and 2012. What kind of con was CYPHAN? Well, it was a science fiction and fantasy convention which looked a heck of a lot like Fantasticon.

Why did CYPHAN end after three years? I’m not sure. In a post to the CYPHAN 3 event page, when asked about the possibility of a CYPHAN 4, Michael Bollow said they were “Restructuring.”

Screen Shot 2015-04-02 at 12.59.49 PM

Now, as it’s several years later and a new event hasn’t surfaced under the CYPHAN name, one has to assume that it isn’t coming back.

But that means that an organization that already had one failed convention in one city, rather than look inward at their next failure, was still blaming everyone else in their new city.

The lack of self awareness is staggering.

Crossing (State) Lines
As much as Michael “Henry Jones” Bollow would like us to believe Fantasticon was Milwaukee’s home grown event, it wasn’t. Mind you, there’s not really anything wrong with an out of towner starting a convention — as long as they properly research and are prepared for the region they’re moving into.

And it all gets complicated when you cross state lines.

Phanatic Entertainment, LLC is, as previously mentioned, incorporated in the state of Illinois. Fantasticon, an event they ran, was in Wisconsin. For a corporation to do business in another state, they are required to register in said state as a “foreign” corporation.

Here’s the thing – as far as I can tell, Phanatic Entertainment, LLC never filed to do business in Wisconsin. I’ve searched the state database repeatedly, and found no evidence of Bollow ever registering Phanatic Entertainment, LLC as a foreign corporation.

Which would be illegal.

In the end, does it matter?
Maybe it doesn’t? I mean, here’s the thing – the convention scene is run by a short list of people. Bollow is not the first person I’ve run across doing sketchy things, and he won’t be the last.

But this is largely a community that runs on trust, and obscuring who is behind an event breaks it. It’s also a community that is served best by convention organizers willing to work with each other, which Michael Bollow seems unwilling to do.

But since he blames the very community he was trying to serve for his own failures, maybe it’s a good thing that he’s exiting the region.

And maybe someone else with a little more savvy, self awareness and communal attitude can move in.

Trae Dorn

Trae Dorn has been staffing conventions for over twenty years, and is a co-founder of Wisconsin’s longest running Anime convention No Brand Con. Trae also wrote and drew the now completed webcomic UnCONventional, and produces the podcasts BS-Free Witchcraft, On This Day With Trae, Stormwood & Associates, and The Nerd & Tie Podcast. This leads many to ask when the hell they have time to actually do anything anymore. Trae says they have the time because they “do it all quite poorly.”

4 thoughts on “Fantasticon Milwaukee’s Weird Web of Lies, Sketchy Tactics and Law Breaking

  • April 2, 2015 at 2:52 pm

    As the person who screengrabbed the conversation (and regrets not having the entire conversation saved before I deleted it), I can tell you what I remember from memory.

    One of the first messages Mr. Bollow sent me accused other cons coming to the area of rooting for the Patriots and liking lobster, and he said I should come to Fantasticon. This didn’t make sense to me and I didn’t initially connect it to Awesomecon because they aren’t based in New England, but after ensuing comments I guess he just grouped the whole coast together. He also baited me with Jayne who if I am correct wound up canceling on them… which I know happens often, but can’t help but find it funny that he tried to do that with someone who didn’t end up being there.

    When I replied that I was from the East Coast, his response was that he wouldn’t hold it against me. That struck a nerve because since I’ve moved to Wisconsin (from Brooklyn, NY in 2011), I’ve gotten two reactions. A few people think it’s cool, but the majority of the response I get is people mocking me. They put on fake accents. Many have said to me “but you seem too nice to be from New York!” … my favorite is being asked if I have mafia ties (I’m Italian American as well). It’s so stereotypical and comical but it happens every time and it just gets on my nerves at this point. Mr. Bollow stopped responding to me when I pressed for some more info on his “con”. I found out, because a few other friends of mine in WI that also “liked” and responded to things on the AwesomeCon page were also getting messages from him.

    Even if he had filed the proper documents… even if he hadn’t used a dummy account to blame the good people of Wisconsin for not supporting him better — I feel the true nature of this individual comes through in his marketing tactic of dragging other cons AND AN ENTIRE COAST through the mud “in good fun”. Sorry, that’s not good business.

    Thanks, Trae, for shedding some light on what else went on here that most didn’t know about.

    • October 27, 2019 at 1:31 pm

      Jayne didn’t appear because Mike tried to short-change him at the last minute. He was able to secure John Barrowman after Adam Baldwin already agreed, and he couldn’t afford both. He figure that he could offer Baldwin less money after he had already cleared his calendar – a lower payday is better than no payday, right? Well, Adam Baldwin didn’t think so, so that is why he didn’t appear.

  • May 5, 2015 at 12:25 am

    That was me asking Michael about Cyphan. I actually had one of his puppet accounts spam my cosplay page when Awesome Con posted on it. It was ridiculous. He is someone looking for a get rich quick scheme but has utterly failed because he of his own ego and stupidity. I actually had a blast at Fantasticon, even won the Doctor Who Cosplay Contest and would have loved to have gone back for a second year.

    For a first year con it was really good, but the behind the scenes junk just ended all chances of that happening.

  • Pingback: Amazing Stories | AMAZING NEWS: 4/5/15 - Amazing Stories

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *